In a Nutshell . . .

It is quite simple, really. If you don't see it right away, read the resolution again.

The resolution defines a relationship that is obviously not one between equals. The New WAM is subordinate to BSBI, and its Board.

Now, I know full well what the original intent was, and will discuss aspects of that later, but the foremost question is why anyone in the New WAM should ask others to accept a subordinate relationship?

Judaism values the individual, and it values human life above all. The value of the individual, their self-respect and honor, these are core values. In the context of establishing and fostering a vehicle of spiritual and communal growth, especialy Orthodox Jewish growth, why should we be so ready to relinquish a core value in this way?

In a nutshell: The resolution falls dangerously short, and pushing it through is an unacceptable sacrifice of first principles.